INFORMS Open Forum

Expand all | Collapse all

Choosing Your Research Field: What Influenced Your Decision?

  • 1.  Choosing Your Research Field: What Influenced Your Decision?

    Posted 26 days ago
    When selecting a research field, many factors come into play. Whether it's a personal passion, a gap in existing knowledge, or practical considerations, the process can be deeply personal and varied.
     
    My journey began when I noticed that I was one of the few who genuinely enjoyed the OR classes in a business department during my undergrad years.  After graduation, I made a sharp turn and joined a master's program in applied mathematics. When I returned to a business school for my doctoral studies, I initially focused on e-commerce and omnichannel retailing-an area where my supervisor excelled. While this was part of my research, I felt something was missing.
     
    A pivotal moment came when I was reading some news on food waste and was stunned by the facts and statistics. This realization and my supervisor's suggested reads sparked a strong desire to shift my focus to this field. Over time, I have forged partnerships with food banks and other charitable organizations, making my work in this area even more fulfilling. Despite the profit-driven nature of most businesses, I believe in people's altruistic potential. The world produces enough food to feed everyone, yet a significant portion is lost due to conventional practices and consumption habits. I believe that OR can be a powerful tool in recovering and redistributing this surplus food.
     
    I'd love to hear from others about their own experiences. What led you to your current research area? Was it a particular event, a mentor, or a specific problem that sparked your interest?
    Cheers,
    Armağan


    ------------------------------
    Armağan Özbilge
    Assistant Professor
    Dalhousie University
    Halifax NS
    ------------------------------


  • 2.  RE: Choosing Your Research Field: What Influenced Your Decision?

    Posted 25 days ago
    Dear Professor Özbilge,
    Dear scholar and friend Armağan,
     
    Thank you very much for accepting INFORMS - and my invitation to provide such a beautiful and biographical contribution!
     
    I remember with joy the old days at METU (Middle East Technical University; in Turkish abbreviation: ODTÜ), Ankara, where you studied financial mathematics with our friend Prof. Dr. Yeliz Yolcu Okur at the Institute of Applied Mathematics (IAM, or UME). This was excellent, sound and thorough training and I believe it has helped you greatly in our young, yet already impressive career in OR-MS, as I have always observed. 
     
    In fact, I believe some readers are familiar with Kurt Lewin's maxim:     "Nothing is as practical as a good theory."
    Now, your main research areas are on sustainable operations, including charitable giving, food waste, hunger, and circular supply chains. Your work is interdisciplinary and collaborative with local, provincial, and federal charities.
     
    This entire educational and professional process seems to me very exciting, and I am sure that INFORMS with its specific Societies provides various platform to share your special experiences and collaborate with other scholars.
     
    Of course, you may invite your friends from Canada, the US and Turkey and any other countries to enter this discussion. 
     
    Thanks a lot to INFORMS for making this new discussion and thread possible and hosting it so kindly.
     
    With best wishes,
    kind regards,
    Willi (Gerhard-Wilhelm Weber)


    ------------------------------
    Gerhard-Wilhelm Weber
    Professor
    Poznan University of Technology
    Poznan
    ------------------------------



  • 3.  RE: Choosing Your Research Field: What Influenced Your Decision?

    Posted 24 days ago
    Dear Willi Hocam,
     
    Thank you for the invitation and for following up.
     
    That chapter of my life holds a special place in my heart. It not only sparked the curiosity that inspired me to pursue a PhD, but also fostered lasting friendships with my peers, university staff, and esteemed professors like yourself.
     
    It's my pleasure to accept your invitation. I am already involved in several interest groups and professional networks within INFORMS, and I thoroughly enjoy seeing the work, thoughts, and publications of others.
     
    Kind regards,
    Armagan


    ------------------------------
    Armağan Özbilge
    Assistant Professor
    Dalhousie University
    Halifax NS
    ------------------------------



  • 4.  RE: Choosing Your Research Field: What Influenced Your Decision?

    Posted 23 days ago

    What influenced my research field (and path to operations research)?

    It's a long story...

    Perhaps I was about eight years old when my mom's father began playing board games
    with me: checkers, one-and-the-four, Chinese checkers, and fig-ee-mill. The rules to these
    games were simple and yet the thinking required to play well was quite involved-or at least it
    seemed so at the time. My grandfather was retired then and spent a lot of time playing these
    games with me. He died about two years later but his influence had not.


    During high school, I enjoyed playing chess. It had the same appealing property of the
    earlier board games in that the rules were simple and yet the thinking to play well extensive. Challenging but enjoyable. My enjoyment of chess was bolstered by some ability. It helped that I was good at the game (largely due to my experience with my grandfather) and won our high school's chess championship. We prefer
    activities we can do well.

    During my sophomore year at Cornell University (1980-81), I took one course in each of four
    engineering disciplines-one of which was operations research. The idea was to sample the
    disciplines and then select our majors. I enjoyed the operations research (OR) course more than
    the others and received an A+ in it. That was enough for me to major in it (rather than computer science which would have been my second choice).

    In later years, I was attracted to production scheduling problems and was involved in addressing supply chain management problems for many years at IBM (and later Clarkson University). Mostly, they were problems simply expressed (what to make when?) and yet complexity/challenge was often involved. Problem solving is fun when we have some ability in it. Conversely, when my car has a hard failure, I am baffled and pay an automobile mechanic to fix it.

    In total, my grandfather may have had the largest influence. Some of my math teachers were more interesting to me than other teachers, but I recall one who was so boring that I could pay attention only intermittently. I liked that OR helped solve useful problems. But there are lots of useful fields. OR happened to be the most enjoyable and satisfying for me.



    ------------------------------
    John Milne
    Clarkson University
    Potsdam, NY
    jmilne@clarkson.edu
    ------------------------------



  • 5.  RE: Choosing Your Research Field: What Influenced Your Decision?

    Posted 22 days ago

    As a student some decades ago, I came across "Optimal Strategies in Sports" (Machol and Ladany, 1977).  This book cemented my attraction to Operations Research and convinced me that analytical methods could explore and solve practical problems.



    ------------------------------
    Keith Willoughby
    Professor
    University of Saskatchewan
    Saskatoon SK
    ------------------------------



  • 6.  RE: Choosing Your Research Field: What Influenced Your Decision?

    Posted 22 days ago

    Dear Professor Özbilge,

    Thanks for starting this thread. After reading about your research journey, I am curious what made you switch from Mathematics during you masers to Business studies for your PhD. Is there sth in particular you didn't appreciate in Mathematics? Kindly share, if convenient.

    Regards



    ------------------------------
    Jayant Singh
    Analyst
    San Leandro CA
    ------------------------------



  • 7.  RE: Choosing Your Research Field: What Influenced Your Decision?

    Posted 22 days ago

    Dear Dr. Singh,

    Thank you for your response. On the contrary, I love math and had the best time during my master's studies. Back then, I felt that the tools I acquired were best suited for tackling business-related problems. The PhD program I completed was highly quantitative as well-one of my co-supervisors is a mathematician, and the other an engineer.

    Cheers,
    Armagan



    ------------------------------
    Armağan Özbilge
    Assistant Professor
    Dalhousie University
    Halifax NS
    ------------------------------



  • 8.  RE: Choosing Your Research Field: What Influenced Your Decision?

    Posted 22 days ago

    Thank you for sharing your insights, Professors Milne and Willoughby.

    It always fascinates me how childhood experiences and games influence our lives. Decision-making is a constant process for everyone, even though we don't always solve every problem on our own. What I find compelling about OR is its ability to quantify and clarify this process. Sometimes, the problems we face are complex, but the solutions are simple, and at other times, it's the reverse. I particularly enjoyed Dr. Milne's analogy of car failure-the issue with the car may be complicated, but for me too, the decision-making process is as straightforward as calling a mechanic.



    ------------------------------
    Armağan Özbilge
    Assistant Professor
    Dalhousie University
    Halifax NS
    ------------------------------



  • 9.  RE: Choosing Your Research Field: What Influenced Your Decision?

    Posted 21 days ago

    I had a BA in Math with a CS minor, which at little DePauw University usually meant you became an actuary or high school teacher. But a summer spent on an NSF project with Wayne Winston at Indiana University introduced me to OR (specifically Dynamic Programming), so I ended up going to graduate school in IE at Purdue. During my M.S. I had a simulation modeling course from Alan Pritsker, which was fun. Then later I was fortunate to take an advanced simulation methodology class from Bruce Schmeiser, which I found really compelling (Bruce was an inspirational teacher). At the same time, I was not excited about the jobs I was being offered with an M.S., so when Bruce asked me to stay I did. I had taken a lot of statistics but found its application in simulation experiments more interesting than to physical data, and still do :-) 



    ------------------------------
    Barry Nelson
    Walter P. Murphy Professor
    Northwestern University
    Evanston IL
    ------------------------------



  • 10.  RE: Choosing Your Research Field: What Influenced Your Decision?

    Posted 18 days ago

    I came late to 'official' OR; I majored in Math in college.  Even then, however, I took an interest in operational problems. I had a job that required catching a circulating bus that ran from campus to the Forrestal Research Center, where they were building a giant cyclotron. Waiting for the bus, I speculated on the likelihood of being late for the next bus. (It turns out the mean wait time is half of the time between arrivals).  

    Years later after an industry career, mostly in computing at manufacturing organizations, I decided to get a PhD.  I was interested in inventory problems, and also in the idea of cooperation in business as well as competition.  My advisor, Moshe Dror (INFORMS member RIP), put me onto cooperative games in inventory, the question of sharing the benefit or cost of pooling inventory.  It turned into a dissertation and several more papers over several years!  

    Later yet, I got a job at Cal State University Maritime, which trains businessmen, engineers, and licensed maritime sailors. I found maritime logistics and economics very interesting, and engaged in several research projects in these areas.   I made quite a few friends and collaborators in that space.   I still did a bit of game theory research, though.

    So a path to research interests might not focus on an area or skill; look for interesting operational questions and think about solutions.



    ------------------------------
    Bruce Hartman
    Professor
    University of St. Francis
    Tucson, AZ United States
    bruce@ahartman.net
    website:http://drbrucehartman.net/brucewebsite/
    blog:http://supplychainandlogistics.org
    ------------------------------



  • 11.  RE: Choosing Your Research Field: What Influenced Your Decision?

    Posted 18 days ago

    Hello Armağan Özbilge and other readers of this interesting and, perhaps, very useful question.

    My advice would be to choose a topic that interests YOU, not necessarily the topic your supervisor is pursuing.  I like that you switched into an area matching your passion.  In my case, in 1979 I finished my Master's research which turned out to be highly relevant to today's neural nets.  Not relevant to my subsequent work for many decades.  But, I enjoyed the research, learned a lot, and now it is relevant!



    ------------------------------
    Duncan Klett
    ------------------------------



  • 12.  RE: Choosing Your Research Field: What Influenced Your Decision?

    Posted 16 days ago

    Dear @Duncan Klett, Profs. Nelson and Hartman,

    Thank you for sharing your experiences. The stories prove how personal the choice of a research field can be. It's also interesting to see how the research process can either focus on applications that are of interest to practitioners or on theoretical work that may become relevant in the future.

    Cheers,
    Armağan



    ------------------------------
    Armağan Özbilge
    Assistant Professor
    Dalhousie University
    Halifax NS
    ------------------------------



  • 13.  RE: Choosing Your Research Field: What Influenced Your Decision?

    Posted 9 days ago
    Edited by Si Liu 9 days ago

    Thank you, Armağan, for the invitation to join this discussion.

    Before beginning my Ph.D. journey in Management Science, I had the opportunity to explore various engineering disciplines, each contributing uniquely to my problem-solving mindset and analytical skills.  However, what truly shaped my research direction was joining a dynamic research group led by my Ph.D. supervisor, Dr. Elkafi Hassini. Dr. Hassini not only encourages diversity in the academic and professional backgrounds of his students but is also deeply supportive of their individual ideas, allowing them the creative freedom to explore innovative research avenues. 

    My specific interest in smart mobile lockers with city buses as the focus of my Ph.D. thesis evolved from my observation of public transit operations during the COVID, as well as my familiarity with the sharing economy as a member of the Smart Freight Center. I sought to address critical challenges in last-mile delivery systems and public transit, ultimately conceptualizing a solution that enhances both accessibility and sustainability.  In addition to my direct research experiences, attending academic meetings in disciplines beyond my immediate field, such as information systems and marketing, played a pivotal role in broadening my perspective, and contributed to my research in the interfaces of OM, IS, and MKT.

    ------------------------------
    Si Liu
    Assistant Professor
    Kent State University
    Kent OH
    ------------------------------