INFORMS Open Forum

  • 1.  Excellent resource on Sustainable Design

    Posted 05-18-2024 11:06

    Hello colleagues,
    Recently, I came across an excellent book on sustainability;  The Philosophy of Sustainable Design by McLennan, Jason F.

    Here are my couple of takeaways;

    a.) There is nothing wasted in nature. Nature obeys circularity laws quite well
    b.) Living with the nature is a better idea to promote sustainability.

    This should be a good read for sustainability fans and in particular, how to design green buildings,

    Regards



    ------------------------------
    Jayant Singh
    Analyst
    San Leandro CA
    ------------------------------


  • 2.  RE: Excellent resource on Sustainable Design

    Posted 05-24-2024 09:46

    Interesting, Jayant.  I had a hydrologist friend. He said water never disappears, we don't "use it up", it's just not where we want it.  Circular water balance!

    Unfortunately he died last year. I miss him.



    ------------------------------
    Bruce Hartman
    Professor
    University of St. Francis
    Tucson, AZ United States
    bruce@ahartman.net
    website:http://drbrucehartman.net/brucewebsite/
    blog:http://supplychainandlogistics.org
    ------------------------------



  • 3.  RE: Excellent resource on Sustainable Design

    Posted 05-24-2024 11:32

    Appreciate your response, Prof. Hartman. It has been estimated that a drop of water on average stays for 10 days in cloud form before raining back on the earth.
    It sounds true that nature has given us very efficient systems, which we're not using properly.

    The above calculation can be found in the book, The Art of Insight in Science and Engineering: Mastering Complexity by Sanjoy Mahajan. It is an excellent read on how we can use simple strategies to break down seemingly complex problems. 



    ------------------------------
    Jayant Singh
    Analyst
    San Leandro CA
    ------------------------------



  • 4.  RE: Excellent resource on Sustainable Design

    Posted 05-25-2024 04:36
    Edited by Rahul Saxena 05-25-2024 04:49

    Hi Jayant,

    I understand that Jason F. McLennan offers a compelling vision for how buildings and communities can be designed to be more environmentally responsible and resilient.

    These assertions, however, need to be examined critically:
    a.) There is nothing wasted in nature. Nature obeys circularity laws quite well
    In general, any surplus provides a niche that a species can exploit, and over long time-periods many of the surpluses disappear, making you think that "nothing is wasted". Nature obeys the 2nd Law of Thermodynamics, so nature's "Circularity" isn't an endless loop. I thought David Deutsch wrote quite nicely in "The Beginning of Infinity" about the fallacy of how people think of nature-in-balance.

    b.) Living with the nature is a better idea to promote sustainability.
    It's difficult to operationalize this assertion. What does it actually imply? In thinking about what "promotes sustainability", this paper (https://doi.org/10.1108/TECHS-08-2021-0003) asserts that it's about reducing footprint. Would be nice to get your thoughts on what it means for you.



    ------------------------------
    Rahul Saxena
    FrogData.com
    ------------------------------



  • 5.  RE: Excellent resource on Sustainable Design

    Posted 05-25-2024 13:09

    Thanks for your insights, Rahul. It is great to see people sharing their thoughts on sustainability.

    Agree with your second observation that, promoting sustainability is about reducing carbon footprint. The way I was thinking is, if we use natural resources in a smarter way, like making buildings suitable to the weather of a place, this may avoid necessity of using artificial resources, like gas/oil to say heat up the house or keep the house cool. In other words, use the sunshine or wind in a smarter way, thereby reducing carbon footprint.
    These are my two cents on it.



    ------------------------------
    Jayant Singh
    Analyst
    San Leandro CA
    ------------------------------